Friday, September 19, 2008

Week Four Blog: Some Discussion of your Second Paper

Week Four Blog: Some Discussion of your Second Paper

For this week you’ll discuss the article in Dialogues that you’ve chosen to write in response to, as well as a little bit about the development of your thoughts about your second paper. Start out by telling which article you’ll be arguing against. Then summarize the argument the article is making. Depending on how much detail you go into, this summary could take anywhere from a sentence to a paragraph. Other points to discuss include:

Why did you choose this article? Had you thought much about this issue before or did
reading the article spur your interest? Do you have a personal interest in this issue?
How much do you disagree with the author? Completely? On most of his or her points?
Or do you agree with a lot of what the author is saying but disagree on a few key points? Your paper can be written from any of these perspectives.
Have you found any other articles in Dialogues that you can use for your paper? Which
ones?
Do you have a tentative thesis for your paper yet? What is it?

Post at least two paragraphs by midnight on Wednesday to get full credit for your participation.

18 comments:

Anonymous said...

HELLO PROFESOR THIS IS JUSTA N. PITILLO, THE ARTICLE THAT I CHOOSE FROM DIALOGUES WAS"THE MYTH OF THE LATINA WOMAN" BY JUDITH ORTIZ COFER. THE ARGUMENT THAT THE AUTHOR IS MAKING IS THAT LATINA WOMAN DO THE WORST JOBS OR THE JOBS THAT WHERE CREATE FOE WOMAN WITH LITTLE SKILL AND THE AUTHOR ALSO IMPLIED THAT ONLY FEW LATINA WOMAN MAKE TO TTHE TOP. WHICH I THINK IT IS NOT TRUE BECAUSE NOW MORE THEN EVR LATINA WOMAN IS WHAT IS MAKING THIS COUNTRY A REAL SRTONG ONE
I CHOOSE THIS ARTCILE BECASUSE I THOUGH THAT IT WAS REAL INTERESTING IN READING ABOU THE STEREOTYPES THAT AMERICAN PEOPLE HAS OF THE LATINA WOMAN.I DISAGREE WITH THE AUTHOR MAYBE IN A 50% BECASUE NOT EVERYTHING THAT SHE SAID WAS NOT TRUE AND SOME WAS TRUE.

Anonymous said...

Hi Professor Barker the essay that read on the Dialogues is “In combat zone” by Leslie Mormon Silko. In her essay she discuss about women safety. She is discussing that women to be strong, and to protect themselves should know how to use gun and they should care gun. I strongly disagree with her because guns are dangers. So I do not know is this right?

Anonymous said...

The article I am responding to is "The Case for a National ID Card" by Margaret Carlson. Her article discusses the benefits of implementing a national ID card. For instance, Carlson argues that having a national ID card, that is, a single ID card that will be similar to “a high-tech, hard–to-forge driver’s license,” will encourage quicker lines at the airport, protection from Internet scams, and even prevent terrorism, which, in a post-9/11 society has become the federal government’s primary concern.

Having been asked this question before, I realized that this is a serious issue because in 2005, the government passed the Real ID Act which puts us on the long, hard road towards having a national ID card. Carlson also approves of this card because on a superficial level it will mean that we won’t have to carry a library card, college ID, driver’s license, credit cards, etc. However, a “high-tech” ID card will basically be a digital finger print. It will store ALL of your information, making you even more easy-to-find, easy-to-track, and, ironically enough, it will be easy-to-forge because if everything is logged in an electronic database there are a number of ways that determined hackers and terrorists can get it, so cases in identity theft will most likely increase. In other words, you’re better off unfurling your cardholder when you get to the counter.

(Also, if you thought you hated going to the DMV before, having a national ID card will make going there a real trip to Hell because you will have to bring twice as much information not only to prove your identity, but to prove that you are an American citizen).

My paper will focus on the negative aspects of having a national ID card and how harmful it will be to US-Canada relations. Our heightened border patrol policies post-9/11 and the supposed illegal immigration crackdown have been detrimental to the way we view our neighbor to the North in spite of years of friendly relation, and a national ID will inevitably affect both sides of the border.

If you’re interested in more information about the Real ID Act then check out realnightmare.org.

-Maat Thomas

eilis soto-Artist said...

Eilis Soto
September, 2008

For the second paper I choose to write about "Racial profiling
" because this is one of most controversial topic in our society today. However, I am not agreeing that racial profiling should be aceptable in a free country, where everybody has the same level of opportunity to live in. In this paper I going to show examples of cases as a proof of racism, and I will going to argue against of that cruel and injustify practice.

Anonymous said...

The article that I’m responding to is “In the Combat Zone” by Leslie Marmon Silko. The main argument that the author was making is that women should really make an effort to protect themselves rather then depending on the police or the court. Furthermore, she used her own experience with a stalker to set a firm alarm and an example to show her audience that women should be brave and gun is an excellent source of protection.

I haven’t really thought about this issue before. Therefore, I thought her essay was great and interesting although I only agree with her in some points. I didn’t really find any other articles that I’m interested in, perhaps I didn’t read enough. Last but not least, my tentative thesis is “In the Combat Zone". My tentative thesis is the following "Even though, I agree that women should protect themselves from stalkers and rapers, but to me thinking of that to let them carry a gun everywhere its just not the solution. Gun can protect them, but sometime it backfires.”

Anonymous said...

For my second paper I'll be responding to the essay “'Gay Marriage' Confusions”, by Thomas Sowell. In his essay Sowell argues that homosexuals should not be entitled to the right to be legally married. He builds his case on a number of points, one being that marriage is an institution uniquely adapted to heterosexual relationships, and that it would not “translate” to homosexual unions. He also states that same-sex marriage is unlawful and its legitimization would blur our definitions of what constitutes socially acceptable behavior, leaving the door wide open for bestiality, pedophilia, and anarchy(seriously, that's what he said).

I disagree with Sowell's views, and not to put too fine a point on it, the willful ignorance, irrational rationalizations, and sensationalistic insinuations which form the basis of his argument make it difficult for me to believe the man is an accomplished scholar. I already knew where I stood on this issue when I read the essay, but I found Sowell's views to be particularly objectionable, and in writing an argumentative essay I think it's best to make an argument I can genuinely commit to.

There are a few other pieces in Dialogues which I can draw upon in writing my essay. These include “The 'M' Word”, by Andrew Sullivan, a firsthand account of one gay man's experience and what marriage means to him, and “What's Love Got to Do with It?”, by E.G. Graff, in which the author discusses her own same sex marriage and provides a bit of historical information on the evolution of marriage practices. My tentative thesis is, essentially, that Sowell's assertion that same-sex marriage is a threat to the fabric of American society is, in fact, nothing more than baseless, irrational dogma.

Anonymous said...

The article that I decided to write about was the "Misguided Antismoking Campaign." The aoutor of this article argues that smokers are not permitted to do many things as the people who are non smokers. Whether its smoking in a restuarant or smoking around their spouse or children. the suthor also states that the public cannot always rely on what survey the government may put out to the public because they are many that contradict one another. Which may cause the public to be confused in the decision making process.
I choose this article because it is an issue that has been going on for years. People are trying to improve their way of living without feeling that they are unable to choose for themselves. Its unfortunate that people have to be scolded for a choice that they have made.

Anonymous said...

The article that I choose to write about is called The "M" Word. This article gay marriages and about a guy who always stuggled with his sexuality as a young child. As a child he was always taught about being a good Catholic child who went to church every sunday and he was expected to aim high in life.
He always felt that a marriage should be between two people that truly love each other no matter who they are. I agree with the writer because I feel that everyone is allowed to life their lives the way they want to even if they want to marry someone of the same sex. Why should they not be allowed to do what makes then happy. I feel that it should also be allowed because gay couples are only human like everyone else.
jasminec

Anonymous said...

The article I will be arguing against is "Where the Boys Aren't" by Melana Zyla Vickes. The writer argues about the low percentage of men in colleges and higher educational institutions as compared to women. The difference between these percentages are widening as the years pass by. Men are fewer in higher institutions. I chose this article because I read about similar argument in my Leh 110 class last semester and it was quite interesting.

This issue interest me most because if the men are not interested in education, no measures should therefore be taken to affect the women who are interested in continuing their education. I therefore disagree with the author completely. I haven't found any article in "Dialogues" that I can use for my paper but I have found articles from different books and this particular article. My tentative thesis is that taking measures to increase the population of men who earn bachelor's degree is not necessary.

Anonymous said...

I practically took time to leaf through some of the articles in the Dialogue; must admit found most of them very engaging. The one I thought was very interesting and quite thoght-provoking was Mark Bowden’s article “News Judgment and Jihad” in which the author details the effort of the media in facilitating terrorist acts. Bowden cites specific and substantial evidence of the media giving much attention to terrorist acts like the beheading of American hostages; Bowden states implicitly that terrorists “prey” on the sensationalistic nature of the media to amplify their message.
He tries to make less the beheadings by asserting that there “were not the most important events in the world on the days they occurred”. Incredible!
I’d go on and on if I have to relate this article to anyone who hasn’t read it. Not only do I disagree with most of his views but find them rather unpatriotic.

Anonymous said...

I will be arguing against Dorian Solot, who says that the idea of marriage is totally obsolete acoording to her point of view and her "studies" of the matter.
In the essay "On not saying I DO" the author express her discomformity to the idea of marriage and she gives many reasons and ideas that sounds perfectly clear and maybe makes sense, but the point that I will make is that she is not the most adequate person to give a perspective about marriage because she hasn't been in a marriage, just like it sounds "marriage".
I chose this essay because I feel very comfortable writing about the topic, due to the fact that I'm 20 years old and I got married exactly one year ago and just now even, without children, I start to realize WHAT A RESPONSABILITY it is and I pretty much have an idea of the matter and I think that I would perfectly develop an essay that would provide to my reader with the total opposite side of the truth about marriage.
The best part is that I read many essays from the book and I practically agreed with most of them until I found this one which I found really disturbing because I'm kind of conservative in a way, and even before I got married I was always against "living together" maybe because I was raised in a broken marriage and perhaps, a well costructed family is all I've ever wanted. So then I realized that this was the one I wanted to be against to.

Anonymous said...

The essay I choose to write about is " In The Combat Zone" by Leslie Marmor Silko.I agree that women are unsafe going out by themself in the night,but it's not necessary for women to carry guns because there's no need of violence and guns are very dangerous.There are others ways women could protect themselves like they could take sexual harrassment classes or they could carry a pepper spray with them.I found a book about woman that had been rape at night and why is bad to go mout in the night called "Date Rape" by David Bender.I choose this essay to write my argument because it reminds me of my parent.They hate when I go out at night because they scare something bad might happen to me. posted by kelsey duran

ChristinaCruz said...

The article I chose to write my paper about is "Combat Zone" by Leslie Marmon Silko. She argues that women should be more agressive when encountering threatening situations. She also argues that women should use guns for protection rather than rely on police and government officials. This is not a topic I have thought about recently, but her essay did spark my interest. While reading her essay I was shocked by the way she avidly supported gun possession. Women should absolutely rely on our government for protection--Women's rights are what makes our country unique from many other counries around the world. Guns and violence are just juvenile attempts at solving problems; in the end they end up causing larger problems.
My paper will generally focus on the negative aspects of gun possession for protection uses.

Anonymous said...

Osephni Igoni,

The article i choose is very interesting because it states facts that are true but at the same time i disagree to them and this article is “In combat zone” by Leslie Mormon Silko.In the article, Leslie's main point is about women protecting theirselves by not relying on the the police, by walking in groups and carrying guns. she gave an example on how a guy was following her and the reactions and the next action to take.
i agree to some of the points that leslie made but carrying guns is not the way out because it won't help at all time especially when it comes to a professional rapist or murderer. Also,relying on your own strength won't help. The police are the ones trained to do that, to protect the people so why hurt yourselve in a order to protect yourselv.

Anonymous said...

Hello Professor. This blog is from Antonio Francis. The article I have chosen to base my second paper on is "News Judgement and Jihad" by Mark Bowden. In this essay, the author explained how the news media is placing extreme acts of violence by terrorists in its news coverage. The beheading of U.S. soldiers to be exact. Though I agree with him that this is news worthy, I disagree with the fact they should stop because that would mean the stoppage of some other media, one of which would be horror movie promotions. Yes these horrific sights in plain view should be withheld but it is nothing us Americans have not already seen. We constantly come out with new ideas, some of which use horrific scenes such as those. So I believe the recall of those pictures and videos would recall other events we are already used to.
I chose this essay because I am a big fan of grissly scenes, no matter what the case may be. I come from a place where everything is out of place so, as i said, this is nothing new.

Yeezy said...

I read Mark Bowdens "News Judgment and Jihad". I found it very interesting. I only thought it would be more challenging to argue against him so i did. He believes that the media is encouraging terrorist to continue with what they are doing. I believe that that is only partially true. It is the media’s duty to report every act of violence and terrorism to the public and that is all they are doing.
I found it hard searching for an article because all that I was able to see supported his idea. I was however able to pick a sentence from and article on line. I wish I were able to hand in my draft for the peer review so that I would have more ideas and constructive criticism.

Anonymous said...

test from Sue

July V. said...

The article that I will be arguing for is "The Racial Profiling Myth Debunked" by Heather MacDonald. The argument of the article is that racial profiling is justify. That black are stopped at the New Jersey Turnpike by the police more than any other race. Also that black on expensive car are liked with drugs dealers and the police stop them for it. The police judge all black people for some who commit infractions.

I chose this article because I like the topic. As I was reading I was interesting on this article. I do not have personal interest but I think that was is happening in this article is unfair. I am completely disagreed with this article because nothing justify a discriminatory act. I found a little article on Dialogues that I can use for my paper " Getting the New Jersey Turnpike State Police to Stop Racial Profiling is like pulling teeth". My tentative thesis is "there is no reason why to make racial profiling".