Summaries and Reactions to Your First Paper
For this third week you’ll be writing a little about your first paper. First, write a paragraph of summary on what you wrote about in your paper for the rest of the class to read. Then write another paragraph or two about what you thought went well in your paper and whether there is anything you would do differently if you were starting over with it. It would also be helpful if you mention to what extent the peer review feedback helped you to revise.
To get full credit for your post, write a couple of paragraphs and post your writing by midnight on Wednesday.
For this third week you’ll be writing a little about your first paper. First, write a paragraph of summary on what you wrote about in your paper for the rest of the class to read. Then write another paragraph or two about what you thought went well in your paper and whether there is anything you would do differently if you were starting over with it. It would also be helpful if you mention to what extent the peer review feedback helped you to revise.
To get full credit for your post, write a couple of paragraphs and post your writing by midnight on Wednesday.
22 comments:
I chose to write about the types of visual argument that different styles of clothing portrays. Clothing style always presents a message to the audience. On a normal day I dont put much thought into what I wear because I want my friends to judge me for who I am. However, when I go to work I have to maintane an attractive appearance to keep customers interested. I work at various music venues in NYC as a promoter, so I have to send a message to people that relates to the theme of the club.
For my “Visual Argument” paper I wrote about my most deliberate means of visual expression, which is drawing. After talking a bit about the concept of a visual argument and what I think might constitute one, I described what effect I wish my drawings to have on a viewer. Primarily I hope for them to enjoy the image on a purely aesthetic level. Also, as a representational artist I want the viewer to “believe” whatever I'm attempting to portray with a drawing. The drawing is a kind of optical illusion; if properly performed it can fool the brain into recognizing some marks on a piece of paper as a person, or a car, or anything the artist can conjure up.
I had some difficulty applying myself to this assignment. Though I find the idea of people constructing statements about themselves through the use of various visual contrivances an interesting subject in itself, I had trouble relating to it myself. I think most people, unless they are involved in commercial advertising or some other field where manipulation of perceptions is a primary goal, rarely if ever make true “visual arguments”. A person doesn't wear a suit to a job interview because it expresses some deep conviction they hold that they deserve the job, they wear it because they know if they don't they won't get the job; I see it less as a visual argument and more as a concession to social custom, and I think that most of the appearances that people put on for the sake of impressing others are just that. Even in my own experience as an artist I find that in creating a piece of art I am less concerned with it's impact on others and more concerned with realizing whatever internal vision inspired me to produce that artwork in the first place.
So I couldn't produce a specific instance from my own experience in which I made a distinct and committed “visual argument”, so I wrote about drawing in general. As a result I think the paper I wrote was a bit diffuse conceptually, and perhaps didn't quite fulfill the terms of the assignment. I feel like I drifted and rambled about the subject of visual arguments, and wasn't as focused as I could have been had I been able to find a more specific personal relation to the topic.
Eilis Soto Soto 1
Prof. Sue barker
ENG 120
September, 2008
To write using visual arguments is easy because there in many visual work wherever we look or glance. I picked one of my paintings that reflect an adult topic about cheating in relationship. Working on my paper on cheating was a good experience. I worked on a theme that I was familiar with. Even I have my own experiences but from families and friends too. Since, I was talking about my own art and was grateful to express also by words. Many people are agreeing with me that cheating is one of the saddest and frustrated situations that could happen between partners. Almost everyone could expose their point of view about cheating as well.
When I first bring my paper to the class and I got feedback from students I knew that I had more work to do. They suggest that I need to clarify my thesis in the introduction. Also, to extend the paper because was to short. This was true I was like outlining first for the first draft; however those suggestions help me a lot to improve my paper being successful at the end. Then when the teacher taught us how to correct the grammar I still had a lot of more to do still. I corrected many mistakes such grammar, the title, parallel structure, sentences fragments, MLA standard format, among others. There is always good to proofreading and look for errors before to handle to the professor, but the papers will never be perfect at all.
the visual argument that i chose to write about is my facebook page because there are a lot of things on my page that represent me and who i am. in the essay, i described the way my page is, the different things i have on there, and my profile picture which is very important.
overall i thought my paper went well but im the one that wrote it so of course i would think so. i thought the peer review was very helpful and with the comments i received, i was able to explain more in detail, and correct the incorrect grammars i had. another thing i found very helpful was the brainstorming before starting the essay. i was able to write all my thoughts down and then create a well organize essay.
Osephni Igoni
The assignment on visual argument, i wrote about myself how people judge me through the way i dress. Dressing speaks a lot about people, to me it represent a lot about who i am, it shows beauty, gentleness and calmness in me.And so i went on discribing how each of the things i listed as part of my dressing says something about me.
I have problem with grammar so i am glad i was able to correct the ones i can after the peer review befor submitting because it helped me make some corrections and explain in detail what i to state in my paper. Hopefully that won't be too much problem any more.
Visual argument basically touches on using diverse visual attributes to appeal to the senses of better still, express a thought. My paper featured an unforgettable experience in my life. I went back into the last couple of years before my high school graduation when I contended with four equally qualified individuals for the school chaplain, a much coveted position in St. Augustine’s High. Well, whiles they (contenders) went about dashing out money and delivering “sweet” convincing words, I resorted to a rather peculiar idea which aided me in being chosen for the position. I invented an idea about developing a drawing of me dressed as a clergy. My friend and I worked hard to materialize this idea and within a matter of days, my name “swooped” the entire school like a “wild fire”. Not only did this idea work for me but it also paved the way for many to follow.
I believe my thoughts were sequentially expressed in the essay. Coupled with this, a brief introduction to the subject matter also helped develop my idea, not to mention the peer review which enhanced the overall essay. I wouldn’t make any changes if I ever had to rewrite the paper. I believe my homework was well done.
I chose to write about my room as my visual argument. I wrote how my room is my comfort zone no matter what it looks like. I wrote that my room is messy and that it causes a lot of arguments between my mom and I. My room is a typical teenager room where there's clothing, books, dark and the bed is never made. My room is a battlefield full of arguments. The reason why I said that is because my mother always tries to order me to fix my room. But I'm the type of person that doesn't like to take strick orders lightly. Plus it's my room and I should have the right to clean or not clean my room. So therefore, I try to make my room as messy as possible so I can prove my point. My visual arguemnt is intended to my mom because she's a clean freak and I'm not. Also I felt comfortsble the way my room looks like.
Writing this paper made me realize my true intentions on why my room looks messy. In my essay the thing i felt that went well was my thesis statement. I made my thesis as clear as possible and i made sure that my thesis fit the whole topic of my essay. While revising the essay, I felt that my struggles were when I was trying to describe my visual argument as detailed as possible. I felt that I didn't make as detailed at first because I didn't want to make a list things out. So I took that into consideration and changed to make it fit the topic of my essay.
For my visual argument paper I wrote about how I used the avatar to show other people what my hobbies are. I explained specifically how the image fits my character. The point of the avatar is to show my audience what I’m into and what I like. Perhaps, we would have something in common.
As many of you would agree that most people are bound to not find any mistakes in their own works. I’m no different in this case. I thought my argument paper was pretty good. In the other hand, I thought the peer review feedback was really helpful. It helped me to edit my paper more thoroughly.
To write my first visual argument paper it was not easy. My first paper was completely incorrect. Before I started to write I thought to write visual argument about my apartment. I started to think. I found it kind of hard and I change my mind. Then I decided to write about my grandfather. From the time when I stared to write I thought that is something wrong with my paper but anyway I finished it. When I did the peer review and I read my classmates essay again I was thinking that my essay is not correct. I send my essay to the Prof. Barker who told me that my paper is not correct so I wrote another on but before I stared to write I reread at the dialogues book about the visual argument where I got some idea how to write my essay. My second essay it was not bad. I believe that I learn how to write visual argument paper but I have to work more to get better.
My first paper was about my expertise in pet care, specifically cats, and what it takes to raise a kitten so that it matures into a healthy adult cat. Some of the important aspects of cat care include their living space, eating habits, health (physical fitness), and grooming, for example, so I organized my paper based on these main factors.
Overall, I thought my initial draft was pretty straightforward and, based on the feedback from my peer reviews, it was written clearly; therefore, it was easy to understand. However, since it was a rough draft I was missing a lot of detail which is crucial to any essay because it shouldn’t be assumed that the audience is well-informed of the writer’s topic. For this paper I realized that it was important to include information such as what type of cat food is best for kittens, how many times a day they should eat, and what signs to look out for to tell if a cat is stressed because it’s valuable for the reader.
The peer review encouraged me to be more detail-orientated so that both the audience and the writer are on the same page. Going in-depth made the paper much more complete which should leave the reader less skeptical and confident that the writer is knowledgeable on their topic.
-KMT
The topic that I wrote about for my first paper was about people having the right to live or die. I personally feel that if someone had an illness that was taking over their lives they should then have the right to express how they feel and what they want to do with their bodies. I feel that it is unfair for others such as doctors to tell you that you have to remain to live and deal with an illness that wont get better. If the first amendment is freedom then why don't we have freedom over our own life. Who are doctors to tell us what to do when they are not going through what the sick person is dealing with.
When I read the peer reviews that were done on my paper I was able to notice the simple mistakes that I didn't catch. This taught me to be more careful with my work and over look it more. Although there were only simple mistakes I will over look my next paper to avoid these problems.
My visual argument was about the dressing I made on an occassion. The dressing showed the beauty of African culture. It showed our audience who were our parents that we were also taught about our tradition in school too. The visual argument I made was a successful one.
The paper was pretty much good. I made few mistakes with my grammar which I didn't realise until after the peer review. The peer review helped a lot since I was able to correct my grammar and also to expand clearly my points. Again the in class proofreading made me feel better with all the mistakes to look out for. I don't think I would have gotten a better grade without the peer review and proof reading since I don't always read over my work after I finish writing.
The visual argument that I chose was the way I dress. Basically, I explained the purpose of the "careless" way of my outfit. How I want people to judge me for my personality and my ideology than for the way I deliver my self on the outside. I always wrote about the differences of POV that I could discuss with my audience, and which is fine with me because what's most interesting is that even if they don't share my perspective, some still want to get to know what's under my not-so-cool outfit.
I also talk about my dissapointment with some aspects of life such as vanity and superficial ideas that I don't find attractive at all. I rather see what a person can offer as a human being than as a pretty face.
Finally, I think that what my visual argument express is what I think about things in general. In other words, that we can find beauty in the simplest and common things in life if we really pay close attention.
My visual argument was about the way I look,what I took with me and what I did when I went to a job interview.So therefore the title of my first paper was "An Job Interview".The first interview I had was given to me by my supervisor so I wanted to makesure I dress appropriately I put some black pants that were neither tight or loose, a nice solid colored blouse,black shoes,small earings,a small black purse and a folder with my resume.It's always important to carry a folder with your resume with you when going to an interview because some jobs might want to see your resume to determine if you have the neccessary skills that are needed for the position,but most importantly you must always demonstrate to dress appropriately and show up on time atleast fifteen minutes before your interview. Basically after doing all of this, my technique worked because I was hired and now I am working at the FortWashington Branch Library. Overall the peer review helped me a lot with my grammar because I had a couple of grammar mistakes. That was basiclly it because my paper was understandeble.It had a lot of details supporting my thesis and I made sure I had focused on my topic.Proof reading my paper and reading the peer review helped me organized my thoughts and paragraghs in the second draft.I think I did well on my paper because I used the book called A Writer's Reference. posted by kelsey D.
Angeleane
On my first paper i decided to write about three things. I wrote about picture for your last year in highschool, how we dress on an elegant event and about myspace.For picture i decided to write about how we try to look on one simple day that we want to look our best. For the elegant event i wrte about how we have to look priceless and we want to look spectacular. For the mYSpace situation i wrote how we get myspace to show people how and who we really are and how people comment our pics on how they thought we looked.
I read my essay over and over again and found many mistakes in it.I believe that my introduction was very strong. I began describing what does the word "Visual" means to me and how i thought people viewed it as.I also believed that my conclusion summarised everything that i wanted to say about wisualization.
One of my peers toold me that i should make it more personal "the essay" because i wrote the essay as a third point of view. If i were to do smothingdifferent i wouldve put my own experience about visualization.
Toyese Adeyeye
My visual argument paper was about my room and it speaks of me. My room says a lot about me that I would not verbally say of myself. My room says that I am messy, unorganized, and a pianist, which are all not true.
I really enjoyed writting it. My english 110 teacher, Ms.O'Boy has really groomed my writting skills and speed. I found it a bit relaxing, writtng the paper. I do wish though, that we could have our drafts returned to us before we hand in our second paper. That will enable us to correct our flaws. Our peers are more capable of giving wrong critisms than the teacher is.
I believe it was a little easy writting the first paper because it was interesting. Now that we will be writting more of research papers, I hope i will be able to cope. I like to formulate my own ideas. That is why i also wish we could engage in more class discussions during class so as to keep everyones mind at work. In all so far I've been enjoying the class and I hope to leave it with a smile at the end of the semester.
Shavar mitchell
The visual argument I presented was titled "The way I dress". It basically spoke about the clothes I wear and touched a little on the fashion industry. I referred to the types of clothes I enjoy,appreciate and frequently wear,the materials,designers and brands.I wrote about my mood influencing color choices and teh statements being made. In its entirety my essay was about fashion on a whole and how it transcended beyond the clothes we wear.
I thought my paper offered strong opinions and I kept it very simple regardless of the topic being the complete opposite. If I were to rewrite the paper I would definitely make it a lot more informative in terms of designers and high end male clothing lines. I would've also spoken about teh business aspect- where clothes are being made and who the targeted demographic is.
test comment
Sue barker's post
test post
hello, there
Expert In My Electrical Field
What went well in my first paper
My first paper was written in response to the assignment prompt and addresses all major parts . I was able to develop a central them or idea and my title effectively reflected the contents of my paper. My introduction includes a clear thesis statement and my points were developed in ways that add to the readers interest. The paragraph in my paper showed transition, logical and maintain a good flow. I also completed all my sentences, and they were all clear.
what I would have done differently.
The paragraphs are too short, I would have join some paragraph together to become one paragraph. Also double space would have been constant throughout the paper.
Posted by: O.Ojo
My fit paper was about a visual argument. I chose to talk about my apartment because I think is what I concern more the way how I like it to look. I described what I do not like my apartment to look by giving specific examples. Also I emphasize what I do to maintain it the way I like it to b, clean and organize. In addition, I told who were my audience that told me that my apartment is always clean and organize.
In my paper I think many things were well as explaining with details how I like my apartment to be and how I do not like it to be too. Also giving specific examples to let the reader the details. The format of the paper that I followed was exactly the one the professor wanted. On the other hand I think that my paper is not perfect and if I start over with this I can do some things different. I will include more details because I did not include enough. Also the length of some paragraph are to long, so I could make more paragraph by dividing the long one.In addition the conclusion is to short, it could be three or fourth more sentences.
Post a Comment