Making sure that any information you use from the internet for your research paper is reliable is crucial. While library databases have built-in safeguards that make them easier to judge, it’s harder to be sure that what you find on a free access website is reliable. For this week’s blog, look at the three websites below that each have information on capital punishment. Write a few sentences about how reliable you would consider each of these websites to use if you were writing your research paper on capital punishment.
Consider the various factors discussed in the readings on evaluating websites found in Dialogues on pages 275-280 and in A Writer’s Reference on pages 339-341 in answering this blog.
http://www.thenation.com/blogs/thebeat?bid=1&pid=1622
http://www1bpt.bridgeport.edu/~darmri/capital.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment#Public_opinion
When viewing the Wikipedia article above, be sure to also look at the “About Wikipedia” and “Disclaimers” links that are on the bottom of the web page. Does the information here influence your opinion about the reliability of this article?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
19 comments:
The topic for this week’s blog is quite thought-provoking not primarily for its sensitivity but also the divergent opinions that can arise from it. Capital punishment has long been an issue of much concern to many all over the world. It involves human life; thus subject to much public outcry on its pros and cons. I had the chance of reviewing all three websites paying much attention especially to facts.
Let’s start with the first website: personally, I’ll never use nor recommend anyone writing a serious paper to utilize any information from there. I took the trouble to carefully scrutinize the site and came to a conclusion (I may not be exactly right) that it was more or less like a blog. It seemed like an individual expressing an opinion on capital punishment with much respect to how various Democratic presidential nominees including the Democratic Party itself has handled the matter. Somehow, I felt it was a little biased. It focused more on one party (Democratic Party) barely stating how the Republican Party entirely considered the issue. More so, it isn’t really clear if the information stated is truly factual as there were no citations or references.
The second website (Wikipedia), I found much convincing and useful in writing about capital punishment. Wikipedia is a very resourceful site when writing any major paper like this (Capital Punishment). This is displayed through the step by step development and citations of every fact. As I panned through the article, I realized most of the tenses had highlighted tabs leading to their sources. Not only that, Wikipedia by its “Disclaimers” and “About Wikipedia” makes it apparent that the information gathered may not be entirely factual as its free edit tab allows any individual to change any information at any time. Notwithstanding that, its consistency in citations makes it useful for any research paper.
The third website I was a little bit at loss with some of the facts stated. Somehow, I felt it was more inclined to someone’s personal opinion, though the author made it more credible by providing citations. I would nonetheless consider the information given when writing a major paper on this subject (Capital Punishment), mostly because the citations would help me get access to other information which would be relevant to the topic.
Overall, I enjoyed doing this week’s blog as it enabled me take time to do one of the very things I do during my leisure time—reviewing and rating websites.
While reading through the internet articles I noticed some questionable material that made me wonder about the quality of the information. It is easy for a person to be mislead by an internet article, especially when that person agrees with the argument being presented. Online sources should be analyzed critially when being used for research purposes.
The first article posted by John Nichols, is not one that I would recommend for anyone to use as a legitament source for information. His argument was presented effectively, but if you analyze it more carefully you would see that it is somewhat biased. It lacks citations for the information presented. Furthermore it is posted on a commercial website which implies that the article was probably written to attract a target audience. The article is also outdated, having been written four years ago.
The wikipedia article is useful for general insite on current information but should not be used as source for research. The information on wikipedia can be changed at any time by any individual therefore making the article and unreliable source for valid information.
The last article on capital punishment seemed more like an opinion that an effective argument. Although the individual cites the information, the sources they use are one-sided. I would perhaps use this website to obtain more information about the subject, but many of the sources are outdated, and therefore I can only use the information for research that is not time sensitive. Although this article is posted on an educational website it is not very credible because it does not list the author.
Web research may seem like an easy task, but with so many people having access to it it can be difficult to decipher credible sources from poor quality sources. This day and age every piece of information presented, whether it be via telivision or the internet should be analyzed carefully.
after reviewing the different websites i have to say that the bridgeport one looks like someone just wrote an essay about capital punishment so if was writing an essay on that particular subject, i would not use this site as a source on my essay because i'm not sure if the person got the right informations and it seems more opinion based rather than facts.
after looking and reading the article on wikipedia, about wikipedia, and its disclaimers i would have to say that the information i learned influence my opinion about the reliability of this article to some extent because you can't really trust most internet websites anyways so wikipedia is just one of those websites.
It’s clear that from the three websites cited, only the article from The Nation on capital punishment is the most reputable. Not only do they update their site on what looks like a daily basis, but they also have a lot of contact information if a reader has any inquiries. (They’re easy to find.) They state their policy very clearly in their Terms of Use and Privacy Policy sections and emphasize that the use of their site is a service. They also state that “the Services contain material that is protected by international copyright, trademark and other intellectual property laws.” However, this is still an internet source and even though it has the appealing Web 2.0 look that we all love, even these sites are capable of making mistakes, including what is considered to be the top of the line New York Times.
On the other hand, the public encyclopedia Wikipedia immediately states that they make “no guarantee of validity.” (So what’s the point, then?) They also state that there is “no contract” and that material from a third party is “the property of their respective owners.” Basically it’s just a message board. Wikipedia would be a lot more reliable if all of the information used was properly and thoroughly cited and moderated, as opposed to any Joe Schmo having access to the site. Instead, it would actually be a concise one-stop shop for all the information available about your topic of choice on the Internet, (like a real database) so it would diminish the amount of time spent researching documents, and in Wikipedia’s case, trying to verify if anything you’re reading is true.
While the third site claims it’s an .edu address, the actual page of the article has no information on the author, and the black background, courier font, and red lettering makes it look like somebody’s music blog from 1993. Although it’s linked to the University of Bridgeport it’s not actually the U of B page, so I definitely wouldn’t depend on this as a source. In fact, I would be more inclined to look at some of the works that the anonymous author cited and continue my research.
-Maat
This weeks blog is very interesting to find out which websites is useful when recieving information for a upcoming essay. This is a great way to evaluate these forms of websites because it can be used for our essay. The three websites contains the same topic which is Capital punishment. While looking at these websites, I quickly questioned myself on how reliable these websites are and if the facts are true or not. It is a great form of thinking which websites is useful or not.
On the first website, it was questionable because it lacks any evidence (like citation) on how that person recieved his information on Capital punishment. It seemed like it was merely the author's opinion. I agree with Roger Arhin when he said that it looks more like a blog than a useful website to get information on. There where no forms of reference nor citationtherefore it would lead me to think that is website is more about the author's opinion than factual information.
The second website was confusing because it looks like an actual essay itself. Although it is the only website where it provides valuble citations, I would reccommend anyone to use this because it does have general facts it the essay.
The third website is the Wikipedia website. This website can go either way. It is good for general information because you can easiely find what you want, but how valuable is it? I wouldn't reccommend this website to anyone because wikipedia is always updated. Therefore it wouldn't the information can be false.
This blog assignment is a great insight in how to evaluate websites that are beneficial for future essays. I've learned alot from looking and examining these websites. This would help me evaluate all of the websites I would be looking at when I'm looking for reference for my essay.
with the first website I felt that is wouldnt be to helpful to me but to others it might. this article lacks citations and it is outdated by four years.
the second website wikipedia cnan not be trusted because anyone can easily go on to in and change whatever they want. therefore this website cant really be used as a reliable source.
the last website also has outdated sources that cannot be reliable. It is posted on a educational website but yet it doesnt contain a author. although the web does seem to be a great place to find information it can not alway be reliable because there are some sources that can not be backed up with proof.
The first website- The Nation, the article or a more specifically blog was written by John Nichols. The author was knowledgeable who had written many other similar articles that have been appeared in numerous newspapers. But, by judging solely on his blog, I think the information he presented is somewhat biased, lack of citations, and outdated. Hence, I wouldn’t use this material.
The second website- Bridgeport, looks like somebody’s essay, with no author. Although, it is an educational website but that doesn’t mean that the source is usable. Also the date of the posting can nowhere be found. Yet one might consider using the works cited materials for expanded research.
Personally I would use the third website-Wikipedia, even though anybody can post an article on the website and the site even stated that it’s not for professional views or advice, that one should find another route if they want an accurate information. Any viewers can change or correct the information on the Wikipedia. Therefore, the quality of the material is questionable. On the other hand, if one examined the site clearly, such as following the links or citations provided in the article, then one might find something usable.
The address for the first wwebsite is a cormecial one for The Nation. There is a post on the blog about Death Penalty. The site has an author which is good but information from the page is not recent. It was posted in 2004 which makes the information of the site not very reliable.
The second website has a lot of information. It has other links that can lead you to another website. It belongs to an organisation, The Wikipedia Foundation. Inc. It is currently up to date. It has other references to other sites. At the About Wikipedia link, I found out that the website can be editted by anyone which makes this website not comfortable to use.
The third website provide more information needed on the topic. It has a works cited page but it doesn't show the author and about the website. It looks like a work posted or done by an individual. I prefer to use this site as compared to the other two since it has more speific things about the topic and again it has it's citations.
Angie-
I believe that the first essay just had an auther and thas it. it did not seem like it was an actuall article. This article is also outdated and writte years ago. Wikipedia is a usefull website to use. Yhe only pproblem is dat anybody could edit theis website. They can put anything the desire and make the person who is using the internet incorrect on useless information. The third website was some what of an opiniated article. i wouldnt trust this website either
Osephni Igoni
Reading the different cite for the topic on "capital punishment" i found that the first website can not be trusted, it is outdated. the second one to me would be much better to use although it looks like the it was someone's essay posted up there but at the same time it could give you an idea on what you are looking for and the cites given would help broaden your option.
The last one wikipedia can not be trusted because is not secured i mean anyone could go in and post informations-valid or not valid. so i would advise the second one is much better.
The blog for this week is very interesting. It gives us the opportunity to go through different websites and compare between them. When students are asked to do researches for a class, they use many websites to write their papers. Some of them are useful than others. From those websites that you refer us to read about death penalty, I find out that only one remark the requirements of quality. For instance, in my opinion wikipedia is not the best we can use. The college libraries have the best source of information. Database provides all the information that we need to base our papers on; because the information come from scholars which already accomplished their researches. Another reason of my strong opinion about wikipedia is because anyone could just add information about topics without any verification. Highschoolers could use wikipedia but college students should use database from college libraries to write their papers. Databases are trustworthy and well investigated.
Shavar M.
The first article is obviously outdated.Some good points were stated and outlined but that doesn't take away from the fact that it isn't concurrent with viewpoints of today.It is a good articel nonetheless.I wouldn't recommend this article to someone wishing to write a paper on Capital punishment.
The second article isn't really an article but rather an essay written by a college student.Once again not something I'd recommend to someone eager to write on this topic. It's embellished with personal opinions and viewpoints so instead of getting a thorough,logical and unbiased view on the subject it turns out to be the complete opposite.
The third site,wikipedia is a public encyclopedia so I'd always advise people not to use information from it but coincidentally it had the most useful information.The citations were useful.The information stated came across as resourceful and devoid of personal views,despite being edited by the public.
Evaluating Websites
Getting information is now much easier to get than money, and with a punch of few keywords on a computer keyboard, a website with lots of information is displayed for public consumption. But how reliable are most of these information?. A closer look at most of the websites shows that they lack reliable information. Lots of information posted on the first website for consideration on this week blog are secondary sources information, these informations are other peoples opinion on different issues such as “ form of torture” or “ the use of force” in the interrogation of suspect. Most secondary sources information on this website “ http://www.thenation.com/blogs/thebeat?bid” is not reliable for a research paper.
A quick look at the second website “ htty://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/capital_punishment#public_opinion” shows that it contains more reliable information, the website stated facts about history of capital punishment, and where it originated from. The website also defined the term “ capital punishment”. It also stated places such as countries where capital punishment was highly favored and criticized. The website stated past and present national constitution of counties on capital punishment. Base on all these well founded information, this website is reliable to a greater extent and can be use for a research paper.
The last website “ http://www.lbpt.brigeport.edu/~darmri/capital.html” is a paper written by an individual with cited works. The author of the paper stated his or her personal opinion and views about capital punishment. The author however supported his or her paper with some good examples. The authors cited work can be consulted for more information but his paper cannot be use for a research paper.
So while some few website can be trusted and be use to research papers, lots of websites are nothing but garbage. Posted by : O.Ojo
In the first Website, “the nation”, author John Nichols uplifts John Kerry’s stance on capital punishment. He is being biased in that he does not pose abstract views to that of Kerry. Also, while checking the reliability of this source, I noticed its date of publish is 2004. There has not been any update on this article and therefore is not completely reliable.
The second website, Bridgeport.edu is outright biased. The writer makes it clear that he is in support of capital punishment. It is an article written by one of the students at Bridgeport. The URL of the website ends with .edu, telling us that it is an educational institution. One thing the article is missing is an author. All he or she did was to provide give citations. This website will be good to cite from, but not for reliable information to write a standard paper.
Wilkepedia is a good website for information but under its disclaimers, it makes no guarantee of validity. They said anyone with internet access can alter its content. This leads to the publishing of diverse opinions which will result to biased articles. After evaluating all three websites, I’ve concluded that none of them are legitimate.
Post ωrіting is alsо a fun, if you know afterwarԁ you can write otherwise it is сomplex to writе.
Alѕo ѵiѕit my website payday advance
hey thеre аnԁ thank you for yοur infoгmatіon – I havе сertainly picked
up something nеw from right here. Ӏ did
howeνeг еxpertise a few technісal iѕsues using this website,
аs I expеriеnсed to relοaԁ the site many
times ρrеviοus tο I could get it tο loaԁ proρerlу.
I had been wonԁeгing if yοur
web host is ΟK? Nοt that I'm complaining, but slow loading instances times will often affect your placement in google and could damage your high-quality score if advertising and marketing with Adwords. Anyway I'm adding this RSS tο mу email and can look out for muсh more
οf youг reѕpective faѕcinating сontent.
Enѕure that you upԁate this again veгу soon.
Here is my webpage: Payday Loans
Link exchange is nothing else except it is just placing the other
person's website link on your page at appropriate place and other person will also do same in support of you.
My web site :: Muscle X
Hi there are using Wordpress for your site platform? I'm new to the blog world but I'm trying to get
started and create my own. Do you require any coding expertise to make
your own blog? Any help would be really appreciated!
My site; payday cash today
Hey very nice blog!
my weblog; money making opportunities
Post a Comment