Saturday, November 1, 2008

Week Eleven Blog: Looking at Third Party Websites

In American politics there are two political parties that dominate the political process, unlike in most democratic countries of the world. For your research paper, you’ve all looked at the Republican Party and Democratic Party websites to get information about how the major party presidential candidates are approaching the issues that you’re focusing on in your paper. For this blog, you’ll be looking at some of the third party candidate websites to see what the positions on your issue are for these smaller parties.
While there’s typically not much attention given to these parties and their candidates in the media, there’s been even less in the last few elections. This is probably because of the perceived influence that Ralph Nader had in the 2000 presidential election as candidate for the Green Party. However, it can be interesting and helpful to see what these other viewpoints are. By looking at a few of them, you may get some additional ideas for approaches to or solutions to your issue that you’ll want to include in your paper. At the very least, you’ll be going beyond the two parties that dominate the news to get a broader perspective for your own information. You aren’t required to use this information in your paper.
For your blog response, report on the positions for your issue on at least two of the sites listed below. Most of the sites cover most of the issues that class members are writing about, although you may have to look at several areas of the sites to find discussions of your particular issue. If you have major problems finding information on your specific issue, choose another issue of interest that does have information available. Talk about things like:

--where does this party seem to fit on the political spectrum? Would it be
considered a relatively conservative or relatively liberal position? Or is it hard to figure out from the information on the website? Do the views seem closer to those of the Republicans or Democrats?

--did you get any new perspectives on your issue from looking at the site?
Is anything new proposed that you haven’t seen on the Republican or Democratic issue pages?

--what would you judge the reliability of the party’s website to be,
using the criteria discussed in the blog a couple of weeks ago and in class? Who is responsible for the content of the website?

--would you consider voting for a candidate of any of these parties
Why or why not?

You can also add your other relevant comments as you’d like, or look at other party sites.

Third Party Websites

Libertarian Party: http://www.bobbarr2008.com/home/skip/?s=0618
Green Party: http://www.gp.org/index.php
Ralph Nader’s independent candidacy site: http://www.votenader.org/index.html
Constitution Party : http://www.constitutionparty.com/party_platform.php
Communist Party: http://www.cpusa.org/ (an Electoral Program is available on the right)
Democratic Socialists http://www.dsausa.org/resources.html

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

I must admit that I was a bit at sea reading the week's blog topic for the first time. Ask me why? Well, just like many, I never imagined there were other contending parties aside the Democratic and the Republican parties. As much as my admission may sound odd, its quiet often common in any country’s political arena. Take my country Ghana for instance, there are many political parties but often during elections, it’s almost as if only two parties are contending and interestingly, many of the past presidents emerged from these two reigning parties.
Like my country, the same could be described about the US. From the time since the political campaigns began, it’s almost been as if only the Republican and the Democratic parties have been running the political domain. Though not so much politically inclined, I’ve been following the campaigns through and don’t recall hearing or seeing any of the rather, should I say “unpopular” political parties running an advertisement or giving any major speech. Even less predictable is their websites, which I took the trouble to go through all.
Candidly speaking, none of these websites are comparable to that of either McCain or Obama. It’s much similar to comparing Dark Night to a low-budget movie. Nothing at all looks serious about the last three websites. As I scrutinized the whole page, I was able to assess a lot of flaws or should I say, a pinch of “this is just like any website”.
Using McCain and Obama’s websites as comparison, I realized that most of the issues raised on these four websites are not necessarily categorized like their proposed economic plans, energy plans and so forth.
Bob Bar’s Libertarian party on the other hand looks a little more formal, though it could have been improved.
I took the pains to view their various plans. My subject for this research is on the current economic recession so I particularly decided to capitalize on two factors, the war and the dependency on foreign oil which I believe have a great share in the current crisis.
Bob Bar’s Libertarian proposes plans similar to that of Obama and McCain. On the war front, Bar proposes a quick withdrawal of troops from Iraq, though he does not state definitely how he would accomplish that. I would indeed have diverse views to give on how “unrealizable” this plan would be, but to cut a long story short, I would say: this is not as easy as he makes it sound. His economic plans are well, quite reasonable. He proposes a stronger exploration of domestic oil and more cutting of government spending. This is particularly ideal as it would reduce the outrageous spending on foreign oil.
It was really hard to decide which second website to go for considering how mediocre they were. Though not so pleased, I decided to settle for the Independent Ralf Nader. His plans to me seem more like an outline. He compares them to Obama’s and McCain’s and strikes a mark sign for where his plans would be most effective. Unlike Bar’s website, Nader scores some major points by categorizing his plans. Most of them are more like that of the other candidates. Nader proposes alternative energy sources like coal mining and nuclear energy, this being very similar to that of the other political candidates. He also focuses more on wasteful spending proposing a federal budget cut on expensive military equipment and rather investing in worthwhile programs like schools, clinics, libraries and sustainable energy resources.
On the whole, I would give the websites 1—5 on a scale of 1—10. None of them merit to be called a serious political party. No ill-feelings but I don’t think I would want to vote for any of the candidates. Why? Their plans to me are very vaguely expressed.

Anonymous said...

Looking At Third Party Website

The bad economy is the biggest issue in America right now, and both senator John McCain and senator Barack Obama has been talking to Americans through their campaign on how to solve the economic problems. Both of them represent their respective parties, John McCain for the Republican party, and Barack Obama for the Democratic party. However, America has other political parties, although they are barely recognized, they have their position, and plans on how to solve the economic problems America is experiencing right now.
Bob Barr of “Libertarian Party” was an independent runner for the post of president of the United States Of America. In his web site, he posted some of his plans on how to solve the economic problem, on the issue of spending and the economy, he said, “the government cannot continue spending at this rate if America is to remain competitive in the global marketplace. The new administration’s number one job will be to drastically reduce spending”. Bob Barr, web sit, 2008. His plans was in part in line with John McCain and Barack Obamas economic plans. Both of them agreed that the Bush administration is over spending and if elected the president of the United states, either one of them, will cut or reduce this wasteful spending. Bob Barr also gave statistic of this wasteful spending.
In his economic plan, the only place the word “ tax ” came up was in paragraph four, where he said “ controlling government spending is a necessary step to enact true tax reform, which will reduce the burden on all Americans and allow them to keep more of their hard-earned money”. Bob Barrs economic plans was not comprehensive enough,
I . His plans did not address what he will do economically for the middle class.
II . His plans did not address how to expand United States international trade.
III. His plans did not talk about how to solve the job problems in America.
I did not get anything new from his web sit, his economic plans are practically empty.
Next stop was at www.votenader.org, Ralph Nader was also an independent candidate as Bob Barr. In his web sit, he has lots of issues that bothers him, but in all, there is nothing like economy in his plans. Ralph Nader was most concern about issues like consumer justice, media bias, and impeachment of president Bush. While these issues are important, America face more bigger problems than what Ralph Nader thought was more important. About consumer justice he said “ The enforcement of consumer protection law, especially against the terrible abuses in low-income community, needs to be given the leadership and resources required.”. Ralph Nader also posted on his web sit issues such as “ electoral reform, civil liberties, climate change, and affirmative action. I did not find any new point on the economy in this web sit.

Anonymous said...

After looking at all the websites listed in the blog, I chose to write about Libertarian Bob Barr and Nader Gonzalez’s plans for healthcare. First of all, Bob Barr’s website is pretty decent it’s similar to Obama and McCain’s websites with lots of information and updates. On the hand, Nader Gonzalez’s website is lack of recent updates in the front page and the website seems boring and unprepared. Also I just could not find out what party Gonzalez belongs in, his website does not state what so ever. Furthermore, the content of the website of Barr was created by Terra Eclipse on the other side, the content of the site for Gonzalez can not be found.

Just like Obama and McCain, Barr also argues that everybody should get access to an affordable and a good quality health care. That the cost of health care is too high and that everyone should be able to access to health care. As for Gonzalez, he also believes that health care is for everyone that we should reduce the cost of health care. In his plan he first tell the voters why we should reform the health care system, which I thought it is very cleaver and give us a sense of the current health care situations. Then he goes on to proposed a system which no other parties has offered called the single-payer insurance program that provides savings for all Americans by eliminates the fraud and inaccurate medical expense.

No, I would not vote for any of the candidate of these parties, since their plans were either too similar to Obama and McCain’s plans or too unrealistic.

Anonymous said...

Bob Barr's website looks for formal. He is the candidate for the Libertarian Party. It is quite essy to find what you are looking for. Barr's energy policy it similar to that of McCain and Obama's policies. He didn't actually propose anything new apart from that of the Democrats and the Republicans. It looks like Bob Barr himself is responsible for the website.
Looking at the Constitution Party website, it lokked informal. It is like an ordinary website. It doesn't look like a website for a political party. At the website, they didn't really explain their policy on energy. They only talk about the alternative sources of energy. You can't get enough ideas from this website. The ideas pretty much are also found at the Democrat and Republican websites.
It really great to know that there are other presidential candidates. Although I couldn't get any new idea fro their web page, I was able understand some few issues the two major parties talked about.

Anonymous said...

The Libertarian Party is liberal because it’s attempting to get away from state government. The site is clear and easy to understand; it’s very similar to the Barack Obama/Joe Biden and John McCain/Sarah Palin websites. The Libertarian Party is liberal because of its philosophy and its attempt to eliminate the state and have a smaller government, but this type of politics doesn’t necessarily work in this day and age. Unlike sixty or even a hundred years ago where there was an abundance of jobs, manual labor and creative ideas were an entirely different ballgame as opposed to now where everything is developing at a much faster pace, so it’s not necessarily about not having a bigger or smaller government, but it’s about the interpretation and the ability to have resources and availability for everybody.


The Green Party also has the same web 2.0 look and easy-to-understand website so they are just a persuasive as the websites for the Democrats and Republicans. Nader gives a great overview of his issues on his site and he recognizes that there has not been much of a change in the last four years, let alone the last eight. He has great views on education in terms of providing equal access and diminishing the emphasis on standardized testing because it has actually has corrupted the learning environment. Their issues are liberal and considered similar to the main goals that the Obama/Biden party are attempting to achieve. However, he considers the “corporate domination of the Democratic and Republican parties.” It’s true that there is corporate domination, but the markets are already established and, like the Libertarian Party wants as well, the infrastructure of our government drastically change anytime soon. Overall, Independent Party doesn’t seem like it wants to abolish the system. Instead, like Obama, Nader wants to augment it and rewrite the laws and hold the government accountable to abide by the policies that protect the average person.

Both sites do have a privacy policy. The Libertarian site also has a lot of content written by the official party candidate Bob Barr himself.

-Maat

Anonymous said...

Angie
I decide to write about Bob Barr and the green party. First of all the way Barr's website its being presented it seem to be like a website from the democratic and the republic party. Barr's policies are similar to obama and mc cain. Just as barack obama barr argues abut the issue of high expenses of the health care. Barr argues about the economical issues very briefly and does not go into details. According to the green party nader has noticed how bush haven't done anything drastic in the united states during his two trems. His issues seem to collabarate with the democrats party. One thing that I found weird was how in nader 's website did not state which party did it belong to. Futhemore I will stick to my democrats

Anonymous said...

The only formal website I saw was the one of Barr Bob. These website seems to consider a relatively liberal position. His views seem very closely to those of the Democratic. He even mention that he knows that Obama is going to be the next president of the United State because we need a new change.Then the websites of Ralph Nader's independent candidacy looks very similar to the one of the republicans website likes Mccain because it does contains as much information it has some brief political issues. None of these websites afortunately has any information on my issue. mI won't vote for any of these parties because for me they don't seem strong enough or convincing in their plans for them to be elected to win the presidential. I think these third parties candidates are basically critize the democratic or republican parties based on the plans they have. They either make constructive or destructive criticism on the political issues other paries have for example like Bob Barr he makes constructive criticism of Barack Obama. He basically supports obama. He thinks Obama is what the USA need to improve the country.He will stop war, increase economic and a good acess of health care.

Yeezy said...

The first site I visited was Bob Barr’s, and just like Roger, I was surprised to see that there were other candidates running for presidency. Bob Barr is a representative of the Libertarian party. I knew independent parties existed, but I thought they were all eliminated after the primaries. Bob Barr has an interesting stand on the war in Iraq, similar to that of Obama’s. He plans on removing troops immediately he gets into position. To me that sounds like an over loaded promise. Unlike Obama, I do not think Barr understands that in order not to destabilize the Iraqi government, the troops must be removed quickly, but gradually. He said “Unlike Republicans, who are calling for essentially permanent bases in Iraq, and Democrats, who have done nothing to counter Republican calls for an indefinite occupation, I would put in place plans for withdrawal without undue delay.” His views like I said seem to be more democratic than republican. Barr is not saying anything we have not heard before. Concerning the war in Iraq, I will say this party is not reliable. His promise is too extreme without any elaboration. The site is completely reliable for information. It is updated frequently and has a sponsor. He is a person I would like to look into since his views and goal does not completely differ from mine. Basesd on his vies on Iraq, I might not vote for him because he does not have a plan.
Nader Gonzalez looks at the war from a completely different view. His ideas are well put. Because he seems to have a broader understanding of the situation we are in concerning the war, I might consider voting for him.

eilis soto-Artist said...

After reading websites that professor Barker suggests to us, I was surprised. I do not know that there were other parties who were running to become governors. Now I understand that besides the two major parties, there are others that may be unknown for the majority of the citizen. However each one has their own plan and proposal that they should develop if they become a president. Some share similitude with Democratic and Republican parties about issues such as economic, health care, jobs, cut-taxes, and energy among other plans.

From these websites I found some of them more interesting than others. Each one expresses their feelings and plans which will bring up the attention of citizen and gain their sympathies. As I am writing about of economic crisis in the United States of America, I choose the Communist party: http:///www.cpusa.org/ because it has good information that relates to my point of view about economic issues. “The housing crisis continues and show no sign of ending; credit and money markets are either churning or freezing up; the stock market is gyrating; unemployment is leaping upward (sharply so in the communities of the nationally and radically oppressed); poverty is up and wages are down; oil and food prices are climbing; the value of the dollar is falling sharply compared to other currencies; the level of indebtedness is astronomical and will be difficult to unviewed in the near term. And we sit on the edge of a financial collapse with all the accompanying dislocation and hardship that it would bring.” This information was very helpful and I am using it for my paper. However is good to know that there The United States of America is a democrat country where any citizen that accomplish the requirements could apply to become a president.